In April 2013, one nonny announced their discovery of the Fail_Fandomanon RPF tag on AO3, most of which was written for Yuletide 2012. The works include such well-known meme presences as Original Male Dog, Nathan Fillion Hating Anon, and a Velociraptor.

The category has since gone on to become a small but active perennial for both Yuletide and meme's own Bad Bang challenge/exchange, with fic and “art” featuring various Critters and Sunnies, Overly Aggressive Anon and related “name” nonnies, and meme-created characters like the hapless gumshoe Dick Booping.